| Saturday, February 11, 2012 | |||||
| Away Team | Pick % | Pick % | Home Team | ||
| Louisville | West Virginia | ||||
| #16 Virginia | #5 North Carolina | ||||
| Miami (FL) | #21 Florida State | ||||
| #6 Baylor | #4 Missouri | ||||
| Kansas State | Texas | ||||
| Cincinnati | #15 Marquette | ||||
| Maryland | #7 Duke | ||||
| #17 San Diego State | #11 UNLV | ||||
| #9 Michigan State | #3 Ohio State | ||||
| #1 Kentucky | #25 Vanderbilt | ||||
| Sunday, February 12, 2012 | |||||
| Away Team | Pick % | Pick % | Home Team | ||
| Pittsburgh | Seton Hall | ||||
| Illinois | #23 Michigan | ||||
| Washington | Oregon State | ||||
| Northwestern | Purdue | ||||
| Monday, February 13, 2012 | |||||
| Away Team | Pick % | Pick % | Home Team | ||
| #2 Syracuse | Louisville | ||||
| #8 Kansas | Kansas State | ||||